{
  "job": "lane-L4-boundary-permeability",
  "model_change": false,
  "no_l4_score": true,
  "preserve_e2_n4_offer_attract_audit": true,
  "no_composite": true,
  "generated_at_utc": "2026-09-10T15:19:15.587429+00:00",
  "elite_legislative_reciprocity_ne_s2": true,
  "sensors": [
    {
      "id": "L4-A1",
      "family": "A_legislative_cooperation",
      "sensor": "cbs_offer_out_party_original_cosponsorship_rate",
      "source": "CEL_CBS_E2_N4",
      "disposition": "KEEP_CANDIDATE",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "PRIMARY_REUSE",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Preserve N4 denominator audit; no recompute"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-A2",
      "family": "A_legislative_cooperation",
      "sensor": "cbs_attract_out_party_original_cosponsor_share",
      "source": "CEL_CBS_E2_N4",
      "disposition": "KEEP_CANDIDATE",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "SECONDARY_REUSE_NO_COMPOSITE",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Never average with offer"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-A3",
      "family": "A_legislative_cooperation",
      "sensor": "congress_gov_raw_offer_attract_rebuild",
      "source": "api.congress.gov",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "REPLICATION_SAME_CONSTRUCT",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "API_KEY_MISSING gate"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-A4",
      "family": "A_legislative_cooperation",
      "sensor": "bipartisan_lawmaking_pathway_counts",
      "source": "LES_CEL_adjacent",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "RELATED_NOT_N4_RATES",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Outcome pathway \u2260 offer/attract rates"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-B1",
      "family": "B_bipartisan_networks",
      "sensor": "repeated_cross_party_cosponsor_edge_networks",
      "source": "Congress_micro_CBS",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "SHARED_MICRO_DIFF_AGG",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Edge-mean \u2260 member-mean"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-B2",
      "family": "B_bipartisan_networks",
      "sensor": "voluntary_caucus_cross_party_comembership",
      "source": "caucus_directories",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "LOW",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Panel continuity weak"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-B3",
      "family": "B_bipartisan_networks",
      "sensor": "compulsory_committee_coservice",
      "source": "committee_assignments",
      "disposition": "INSUFFICIENT",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Forced co-presence \u2260 permeability"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-C1",
      "family": "C_cross_party_social",
      "sensor": "cross_party_friendship_discussion_surveys",
      "source": "Pew_YouGov_AFS",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "mass",
      "notes": "Not elite; item audit needed"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-C2",
      "family": "C_cross_party_social",
      "sensor": "anes_discussant_party_items",
      "source": "ANES_CDF",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "mass",
      "notes": "Sparse/irregular; \u2260 S1 FT"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-D1",
      "family": "D_institutional_reciprocity",
      "sensor": "offer_attract_separate_plus_gap_descriptive",
      "source": "E2_N4_audit",
      "disposition": "KEEP_CANDIDATE",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "IS_THE_AUDIT",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Preserve contrary directions; not a score"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-D2",
      "family": "D_institutional_reciprocity",
      "sensor": "selective_reciprocity_lawmaking_designs",
      "source": "academic_replication",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "THEORY_ADJACENT",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Not landed continuous SRP series"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-D3",
      "family": "D_institutional_reciprocity",
      "sensor": "gss_generalized_trust",
      "source": "GSS",
      "disposition": "INSUFFICIENT",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "mass",
      "notes": "S2 corroboration only; \u2260 elite reciprocity"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-E1",
      "family": "E_cross_group_civic",
      "sensor": "bridging_civic_membership_cross_cutting",
      "source": "GSS_civic_bridging_surveys",
      "disposition": "MODIFY",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "mass",
      "notes": "Density uneven"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-E2",
      "family": "E_cross_group_civic",
      "sensor": "bridging_program_participation_counts",
      "source": "program_admin",
      "disposition": "INSUFFICIENT",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "mass",
      "notes": "Selection; not population panel"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-X1",
      "family": "X_guardrail_polarization",
      "sensor": "voteview_between_party_center_distance",
      "source": "E2_N3",
      "disposition": "INSUFFICIENT",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "ADJACENT_NOT_PERMEABILITY",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "ELITE_IDEOLOGICAL_SEPARATION"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-X2",
      "family": "X_guardrail_polarization",
      "sensor": "party_unity_or_within_party_nominate_sd",
      "source": "E2_N1_N2",
      "disposition": "INSUFFICIENT",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "elite",
      "notes": "Cohesion/dispersion LEVEL"
    },
    {
      "id": "L4-X3",
      "family": "X_guardrail_polarization",
      "sensor": "outparty_feeling_thermometer_gap",
      "source": "S1_ANES_Pew",
      "disposition": "INSUFFICIENT",
      "e2_n4_overlap": "NONE",
      "layer": "mass",
      "notes": "Affect \u2260 interaction"
    }
  ],
  "verdict_summary": {
    "KEEP_CANDIDATE": [
      "L4-A1",
      "L4-A2",
      "L4-D1"
    ],
    "MODIFY": [
      "L4-A3",
      "L4-A4",
      "L4-B1",
      "L4-B2",
      "L4-C1",
      "L4-C2",
      "L4-D2",
      "L4-E1"
    ],
    "INSUFFICIENT": [
      "L4-B3",
      "L4-D3",
      "L4-E2",
      "L4-X1",
      "L4-X2",
      "L4-X3"
    ]
  }
}